10 Copycat Arby's Recipes (2024)

Learn the best homemade recipes for Arby's roast beef sandwiches, Arby's sauce, and more!

By: Josh Henreckson, Editor, AllFreeCopycatRecipes.com

Arby's occupies a fairly unique space in the fast food universe. It's not a burger restaurant, a chicken restaurant, a Tex-Mex restaurant, or even a typical sandwich shop. But that's what makes Arby's so loveable: it does its own thing in a way no other fast food restaurant does and it does it deliciously.

As special as Arby's food can be, though, their recipes aren't all mysteries. This list of 10 Copycat Arby's Recipes unlocks the flavor combination behind some of their most iconic foods from their sandwiches, to their desserts and sides, and even to their signature sauces.

Whatever flavor you're craving, these copycat recipes will give you everything you need to enjoy all the delicious tastes of Arby's without stepping foot in a restaurant. Enjoy seasonal items year-round, revel in the deliciousness of your own homemade cheese sauce, be proud of the mountains of tender roast beef you create, or you could always take things down a notch and create a healthier, budget-friendly version instead. What you choose is up to you.

Sign Up for More Free Copycat Recipes

1. Copycat Ham and Cheddar Melt

We started here instead of the classic Beef 'n Cheddar because, well, look at this sandwich! This delicious recipe has everything you need to construct the perfect Arby's copycat from the bun, to the meat, to the amazing, melty cheddar sauce.

  • Get This Recipe

2. Copycat Curly Fries

No trip to Arby's is complete without a side of their crispy curly fries. This oven-baked version makes enjoying them at home super easy, not to mention much healthier. Pair these with another of these copycats or just make them up on their own; they're more than tasty enough to work as a midafternoon (or midnight) snack.

  • Get This Recipe

3. Copycat Arby's Sauce

You can't talk about the unique flavors of Arby's without talking about Arby's Sauce. It goes so well with everything on the menu and really brings out the great flavor of some of our favorite menu items. Thankfully, the secret behind this "secret sauce" has been cracked!

  • Get This Recipe

4. Copycat Apple Turnover

Whether you're an apple turnover fanatic or you've always passed them over for curly fries and a shake, now is the perfect time to try these delicious, flakey desserts at home. They definitely taste as good as they look.

  • Get This Recipe

5. Copycat Beef and Cheddar Sandwich

Is it fast food blasphemy to suggest that you may like this homemade version of the Beef 'n Cheddar more than the original? Maybe, but that doesn't make it any less true.

  • Get This Recipe

6. Copycat Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich

It's hit or miss whether you'll ever see this select seasonal item show up on the menu of an Arby's near you. If you've tasted it before, you're probably craving it now, and if you haven't, you need to. Thankfully, you can now enjoy this elusive sandwich anytime, anywhere.

  • Get This Recipe

7. Copycat Chicken Bacon and Swiss Sandwich

This sandwich is a mess, just like all the best Arby's sandwiches. You'll fall in love with this flavor combination from bite #1. How could you not? It's got bacon.

  • Get This Recipe

8. Copycat Jamocha Shake

Another Arby's classic and a perfect chaser to the heavier flavors that you're sure to have enjoyed earlier in the meal. There's nothing like the refreshing blast of coffee-flavored ice cream to cleanse your pallet and help you relax after a mouthwatering meal of Arby's copycats.

  • Get This Recipe

9. Copycat Cherry Turnovers

Cherry may not be as popular a flavor as apple, but Arby's cherry turnover desserts refuse to play second fiddle. They're every bit as good as their apple counterparts, and the homemade version is the same way. Try it if you don't believe us!

  • Get This Recipe

10. Copycat Horsey Sauce Recipe

There's no way Horsey Sauce was getting left off the list. It may not be as popular as Arby's Sauce, but it's a good bet that this is more due to the name difference than the flavor. Horsey sauce is no joke. It's also shockingly easy to make for the flavor kick it's packing. If you've never given this signature sauce a chance, you're missing out.

  • Get This Recipe

Up next:

The Best McDonald's Copycat Recipes
What's your favorite item off the Arby's menu?
Let us know in the comments!

10 Copycat Arby's Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What is the unhealthiest thing at Arby's? ›

Worst: Corned Beef Reuben Sandwich

The Corned Beef Reuben sandwich at Arby's is considered unhealthy due to its high sodium content, says Wan Na Chun, MPH, RD, CPT of One Pot Wellness. Chun shares that this sandwich has almost 2,400 milligrams of sodium which is more than the USDA's daily recommended limit of sodium.

What is the Arby's sauce? ›

On the other end of the spectrum, you have Arby's Sauce. This one is a tomato and vinegar-based sauce — almost like a cross between ketchup and barbecue. Arby's Sauce has a signature taste without being too far removed from what customers already know and love, making it unique and craveable.

What are the ingredients in Arby roast beef? ›

Roast Beef: Beef, Water, Salt, Sodium Phosphates. Roast Ham: Ham Cured With: Water, Salt, Dextrose, Sodium Phosphate, Sodium Erythorbate, Smoke Flavoring, Sodium Nitrite. Roast Turkey: Turkey Breast, Turkey Broth, Contains 2% or less of the following: Salt, Brown Sugar, Modified Food Starch, Dextrose, Sodium Phosphate.

What are the ingredients in Arby's beef and Cheddar? ›

We took our famous roast beef, topped it with Cheddar cheese sauce and zesty Red Ranch and served it on a toasted onion roll.

What is the healthiest sandwich you can get at Arby's? ›

Arby's classic roast beef sandwich is the most nutritious main menu item. Accompanied by a healthy beverage and a side salad, it can make for a smart meal choice.

Why is Arby's so unhealthy? ›

The thing to know about arby's is this: Most of the items on their menu are fairly high in sodium and, at least when I worked there in 07′-08′, none of the choices were low in carbs so probably not a great choice for people with high blood pressure or diabetes.

What is Arby's best known for? ›

Arby's is best known for selling roast beef sandwiches. Other menu items the chain is known for include gyros, wraps, chicken sandwiches, and milkshakes.

Why is Arbys called Arbys? ›

The brothers took a chance and on Thursday, July 23, 1964, when they opened their first quick service roast beef sandwich shop in Boardman, Ohio. They were going to call it “Big Tex,” but that name was already in market use, so they called the shop “Arby's” based on the initials of “R” and “B” of Raffel Brothers.

What is Arby horsey sauce made of? ›

Soybean Oil, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Distilled Vinegar, Corn Syrup, Modified Cornstarch, Egg Yolk, Salt, Horseradish Powder, Mustard Flour, Natural Flavor, Sodium Benzoate (Preservative), Calcium Disodium EDTA Added To Protect Flavor.

What oil does Arby's fry in? ›

According to Arby's website as of May 2022, the oil Arby's fries are cooked in is a blend of: “Corn Oil, Soybean Oil, Canola Oil, Hydrogenated Soybean Oil, with Dimethylpolysiloxane (to reduce foaming).”

What part of the cow does Arby's roast beef come from? ›

The "Arby's we grew up on" was a Steamship Round. That is the entire "round primal" shown in diagram. However, several years ago they went to a processed version in order to make production more uniform, I believe it is likely still 'mostly' round that has been pressed and shaped.

Why is Arby's roast beef pink? ›

Arby's roast beef is still pink, it isn't fully cooked. Just like when you cook steak, their roast is cooked more to medium rare. So when you are buying your roast beef you have the option to buy Rare Roast Beef from the deli. It is perfectly safe to eat and is cooked.

What is Arby's chicken made of? ›

Arby's Premium Chicken Nuggets, Chicken Tenders and Crispy Chicken Sandwiches are the real deal, made from 100% premium chicken breast. Get your nuggets, tenders or chicken sandwich just the way you want. You can adjust your order with a variety of sauces or additional fixings.

What is Arby's new burger made of? ›

They publicly stated that their new "Wagyu Burger" is in fact a mixture of 52% "American Wagyu" and 48% Angus Beef. If you read our blog and or follow us on social media we've spoken at length about American Wagyu being (at best) a 50-50 cross between Wagyu and (typically) Angus beef.

What is the highest calorie item at Arby's? ›

Arby's: Triple Decker Sandwich

At 1,030 calories, it's the highest on the menu, and that's because of everything on it: oven-roasted turkey breast, pit-smoked ham, roast beef, pepper bacon, Swiss cheese, cheddar cheese, mayo, spicy brown mustard, onion, tomato, and lettuce, all on toasted honey wheat bread.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated:

Views: 6219

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.